Senator-judges at Vice President Sara Duterte's impeachment trial warned her defense lawyers on Thursday, November 19, that replaying video clips of the late Chief Justice Renato Corona would do little to help her case, pointing out that Corona was convicted in 2012 despite airing the same complaints of persecution.
The exchange, according to CDN Digital, came as defense counsel Mark Vinluan screened portions of Corona's testimony from his own impeachment trial in a bid to argue that government agencies had harassed the former chief justice and his family over his alleged ill-gotten wealth.
Why the Corona clips drew objections
Midway through the presentation, Senator-judge Raffy Tulfo cut in to question the relevance of the footage and delivered a blunt reminder: Corona was convicted for lying in his Statement of Assets, Liabilities, and Net Worth.
Thank you to the defense for showing a video of the late Chief Justice Corona, Tulfo said in Filipino. But let me remind you, Corona was impeached and convicted because he did not tell the truth in his SALN, right?
Vinluan accepted the point, answering that it was well taken. Inquirer.net reported that the moment underscored the central danger for the defense: the precedent they invoked ended in a conviction, not an acquittal.
Prosecution calls the videos an appeal to emotion
Public prosecutor and Akbayan Representative Chel Diokno then rose to object, saying Corona's statements had no bearing on the vice president's trial because the circumstances of the two cases differ.
I do not see the relevance of the statements made by Chief Justice Corona about his alleged persecution, except that it is an appeal to emotion that I believe has no place in this impeachment trial, Diokno said.
He added that the clips amount to hearsay because Corona, who died of cardiac arrest in April 2016, cannot be cross-examined, and that no evidence of persecution has been presented in the current case.
Escudero allows the clips, at the defense's peril
Vinluan asked Senate Impeachment Court Presiding Officer Francis Escudero for the same leeway the prosecution had enjoyed with its own witnesses. Escudero granted it, but with a pointed warning.
We'll allow it, and as pointed out by Senator-judge Raffy, at their peril as well, because we know what happened with respect to that case, Escudero said.
The Daily Tribune noted that the presiding officer's caution reflected the court's unease with arguments that lean on a precedent which ended in removal from office.
Santiago video also questioned
The defense did not stop with Corona. It also played remarks by the late Senator Miriam Defensor-Santiago from the 2012 trial, in which she criticized the prosecution for withdrawing several articles of impeachment.
That drew fresh objections. Senator Erwin Tulfo urged the defense to let the departed rest, saying in Filipino: That is a different case, this is a different case, this is a different set of senators, the olden times were different. I really do not understand why we are watching this.
Senator Panfilo Lacson was equally unmoved, saying he could not see the significance of the opinion of one of 24 senator-judges in the 2011 impeachment trial of Corona. ABS-CBN reported that Escudero later said he agreed with both observations.
Where the trial stands now
The defense has presented seven witnesses since November 9. Prosecution members maintain that the testimonies have failed to rebut evidence that Duterte allegedly holds unexplained wealth she did not declare in her SALN.
Prosecution spokesperson and Lanao del Sur Representative Zia Alonto Adiong said the allegations under Article II remain undisputed, and that in some respects the defense witnesses even strengthened the prosecution's arguments.
FAQ
Why did the defense show Renato Corona's video at Sara Duterte's trial?
Defense counsel Mark Vinluan played clips of Corona claiming he was harassed by government agencies, apparently to argue that impeached officials can face politically motivated pressure.
What happened to Renato Corona?
Corona was convicted by the Senate impeachment court in 2012 for failing to disclose assets in his SALN and was removed from office. He died of cardiac arrest in April 2016.
How did the senator-judges respond to the videos?
Raffy Tulfo and Erwin Tulfo questioned their relevance, Panfilo Lacson called them insignificant, and Presiding Officer Francis Escudero allowed them while warning the defense it was proceeding at its own peril.
