A defense witness told Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial on Friday, November 20, 2026, that he could not explain why Cale88 Foods Corp. received P776.64 million while declaring P208.49 million in sales.
Trade Undersecretary Ceferino Rodolfo, who also heads the Board of Investments as managing head, faced questions about the gap between bank inflows and revenue at the company owned by Manases Carpio, the vice president’s husband. His answers placed the documents submitted by Cale88 against records from the Anti-Money Laundering Council, or AMLC.
What the AMLC records showed
Senate President Sherwin Gatchalian cited AMLC records covering 2022 to 2025 as he questioned Rodolfo during the defense presentation. He asked whether Cale88 might have undervalued its sales or failed to declare their full value, pointing to the distance between the two sets of figures, according to CDN Digital.
“Could there have been an undervaluation of sales, or a failure to declare the full amount? Based on your analysis, and given your years of experience at the DTI and your familiarity with companies applying for incentives, what could explain such a significant discrepancy in the figures?” Gatchalian asked.
Gatchalian said the total would still fall short of P776 million even if about P20 million in shareholder advances were added. Rodolfo then conceded that nothing in the company’s operations or submissions to the investment agency explained inflows above its declared revenue.
“Based on the company’s operations and the documents it submitted to us, I see no reason why its inward remittances should exceed the declared sales revenue it reported to us,” Rodolfo said.
Rappler’s account of the testimony similarly reported that Rodolfo found no basis in Cale88’s papers for remittances exceeding its declared sales. The witness did not identify where the additional money originated or offer an alternative explanation for the entries.
Cale88 sales, exports and reported losses
Rodolfo said bank certificates submitted to the Board of Investments showed combined sales of approximately P41 million for 2023 and 2025. He identified 2024 as the year with Cale88’s highest reported export sales, at P150 million.
Senator-Judge Bam Aquino then turned to Bureau of Internal Revenue records submitted to the impeachment court. Those records listed the following losses for Cale88:
- P42,255 in 2022
- P1.88 million in 2023
- P61.5 million in 2024
- P48,000 in 2025
Rodolfo said the company recorded income of P375,000 in 2025, the same year its ownership changed. Aquino pointed out that the BIR submission instead showed a negative P48,000 for that year.
“Well, based on the BIR’s submission to this court, it was negative P48,000. But in any case, lugi yung kumpanya,” Aquino said, using the Filipino word lugi to describe a business operating at a loss.
Rodolfo agreed that Cale88 was losing money. The exchange left the court with differing figures for 2025 alongside the broader question of how a company reporting losses and limited sales could receive remittances worth hundreds of millions of pesos.
Questions over P315 million from China
Aquino said he could not understand the AMLC inflows previously raised by Gatchalian and Senator Risa Hontiveros. He cited roughly P700 million entering the company, including P315 million from China, against declared sales of P208 million.
“Some P700 million came in, of which P315 million came from China. This has been brought up, yet the company declared only P208 million in earnings. Can you offer any explanation as to how that could have happened?” Aquino asked.
Rodolfo answered that P208 million was the amount supported by Cale88’s operations and declarations to the Board of Investments. He said the documents gave no indication of another income source beyond that business.
“All I can say, Your Honor, is that based on our understanding of their operations and the declarations they submitted to us, they have no other source of income apart from this particular business operation,” he said.
“So, if you ask me how much they should be receiving, it should only be this amount. As to the other sources, I would be purely guessing,” Rodolfo added.
GMA News Online reported that the defense witness saw no reason for Cale88’s income to exceed P208 million during the four-year period. His testimony did not resolve the source or purpose of the remittances from China.
Why the testimony matters in the impeachment trial
Prosecutors have accused Duterte of amassing unexplained wealth, failing to fully disclose her assets and engaging in business activities while holding office. The Cale88 questioning concerns financial records tied to her husband’s company, not a separate finding announced by Rodolfo against the vice president.
The testimony nevertheless gave senator-judges a direct comparison between documents filed with an investment agency and financial intelligence records. Rodolfo spoke as a defense witness, but his answers supported neither a business explanation for the gap nor an estimate based on shareholder advances.
No source of the additional funds was established during the exchanges reported Friday. Rodolfo also did not say that the discrepancy, by itself, proved a particular offense. His final position was narrower: Cale88’s own submissions supported P208 million, and anything beyond that would require him to guess.
Questions about the Cale88 testimony
Who was the defense witness questioned about Cale88?
Ceferino Rodolfo, an undersecretary of the Department of Trade and Industry and managing head of the Board of Investments, testified in Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial.
How large was the gap between Cale88’s inflows and sales?
Gatchalian cited P776.64 million in inward remittances and P208.49 million in declared sales from 2022 to 2025, based on AMLC records and company figures discussed in court.
Did Rodolfo explain where the additional money came from?
No. Rodolfo said Cale88’s documents showed no other source of income and that answering questions about other sources would be “purely guessing.”
